Thanks for taking the time to help keep the scorecard accurate. Every edit you submit is reviewed by ASVA before it goes live; nothing you write is published automatically; following this guide makes it far more likely your suggestion is accepted as-is, and quickly.
The scorecard's credibility rests on every claim being checkable. For each bullet point you add or change, include a source; this could be a link to the MP's own statement, a vote record, a written question, a campaign signatory list, or comparable public record. A bullet with no source is the single most common reason a submission is sent back, so this alone will save you a round trip.
ASVA tracks engagement with catastrophic and extinction-level AI risk and superintelligence specifically, not AI policy in general. Without a position on, or work on, superintelligence or extinction-level risk, no MP can be graded above a C, however active they are on AI more broadly.
The things that count as an x-risk signal are:
Use this table to see which grade the evidence supports:
| Grade | What it looks like |
|---|---|
| A | Signed the Sobel letter and either ControlAI or the PauseAI letter to the PM; or one x-risk signal plus active work on x-risk specifically, e.g. co-sponsoring the AI kill-switch amendment, leading a debate on extinction-level risk, or sponsoring a superintelligence bill. General AI activity (copyright, jobs, the NHS, deepfakes) does not lift a card to A. |
| B | One x-risk signal (see the list above) plus whatever general AI record they have, e.g. a ControlAI signatory with little else on record, or an MP who posted backing a superintelligence ban. |
| C | No x-risk signal, but has pushed for regulation of AI in some way, e.g. called for an AI regulator or statutory safeguards, backed a bill or amendment regulating AI (even a narrow one, such as on AI chatbots and children), or pressed ministers to bring forward AI legislation. Warning that AI is dangerous is not enough on its own; the MP must have asked for AI to be regulated, overseen or limited. |
| ? | Not scored. There isn't enough public information, or the MP's AI record is neutral or mixed: questions about using or adopting AI, AI and copyright on its own, or warnings about AI risks without any push for regulation. This is not a negative grade. |
| D | Puts growth or innovation ahead of safeguards without campaigning against them, e.g. championing the UK as an "AI powerhouse", deferring promised safeguards, or rejecting a superintelligence ban as stifling innovation. |
| E | Actively works against AI safety governance, e.g. urging cuts to AI regulation, attacking AI rules as red tape, or calling a pause on AI a betrayal. |
| F | Clear, vocal dismissal of AI risk and its regulation, e.g. calling AI risk "hype" or "doomerism", or saying a slowdown or pause is impossible because AI is a race to win. |
| DNR | Did not respond. Set by ASVA only, after it has contacted the MP and had no reply; please don't propose it. |
A low grade needs evidence just as a high one does: never infer opposition from silence. If you're unsure between two grades, propose the lower one and explain why in your bullets; the reviewer makes the final call.
An ASVA reviewer checks your suggested edit against the sources you provided. You'll get an email either way: if it's published, whether it went live exactly as you wrote it or with some changes; if it isn't, a short note on why not so you can try again.